Choosing the Right Greenhouse Glazing: Polycarbonate vs. Glass

Choosing between a polycarbonate greenhouse vs glass structure is a important decision.

The material you select directly impacts light transmission, insulation, durability, cost, and ultimately, the success of your plants. 

Polycarbonate, a robust thermoplastic polymer, has gained popularity in structure construction due to its excellent insulation, impact resistance, and lightweight nature.

Affiliate Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.

Key Benefits of Polycarbonate

• Impact Resistance: Polycarbonates offer far greater resistance to breakage than traditional glazing, making them a safer choice, especially in areas prone to hail, strong winds, or accidental impacts.
• UV Protection: Most polycarbonate sheets are treated with UV-blocking coatings. This protects plants from harmful ultraviolet radiation while allowing the beneficial wavelengths of light needed for photosynthesis to pass through.
• Energy Efficiency: Polycarbonates, particularly multi-wall varieties, provide superior thermal insulation compared to standard glazing. This helps maintain a more stable temperature inside the structure, reducing heating costs in colder months and potentially reducing cooling needs in warmer climates.
• Lightweight: Easy to cut and handle.

Poly Greenhose From Amazon

Priced at $999.99, with a customer rating of 4.6 out of 5 stars, this Jocisland 7.5×11.2×7.4 FT greenhouse is a popular choice.  It features an aluminum frame, polycarbonate panels, ventilation, a rain gutter, and two swing doors with hooks.

Find the greenhouse on Amazon here

Polycarbonate Options: Understanding the Differences

Is all polycarbonate the same? Absolutely not. Choosing the right type of polycarbonate is just as important as choosing between polycarbonate and glazing.

Single-Wall Polycarbonate

Single-wall polycarbonate sheets are the most economical option, but they offer the lowest level of insulation.

• Description: A single, solid sheet of polycarbonate.
• Pros: Most affordable polycarbonate, lightweight, easy to handle and install.
• Cons: Lowest insulation (R-value), less durable than multi-wall options, provides minimal protection against temperature fluctuations.
• Best Use Cases: Mild climates with minimal temperature swings, seasonal use (e.g., extending the growing season slightly), covering cold frames or small plant protectors. Not ideal for year-round growing in most climates.
• Estimated Cost: The least expensive polycarbonate option.
• Lifespan: 5-10 years, depending on UV protection and exposure to the elements.

Twin-Wall Polycarbonate

Twin-wall polycarbonate features two layers of polycarbonate separated by air channels, significantly improving its insulating capabilities. How does this compare to single-wall for insulation? It’s a substantial upgrade.

• Description: Two parallel sheets of polycarbonate connected by vertical ribs, creating air pockets that trap heat.
• Pros: Good insulation (significantly higher R-value than single-wall), good light diffusion (reduces hot spots), more durable than single-wall.
• Cons: More expensive than single-wall, slightly lower light transmission than single-wall.
• Best Use Cases: Moderate climates with noticeable temperature variations, extending the growing season considerably, suitable for a wider range of plants than single-wall.
• Estimated Cost: Mid-range price point.
• Lifespan: 10-15 years, with proper care and UV protection.
• Thickness: Commonly available in 4mm, 6mm, and 8mm thicknesses. Thicker sheets provide better insulation.

Multi-Wall Polycarbonate

Multi-wall polycarbonate (including triple-wall and more) provides the highest level of insulation available in polycarbonate glazing. Is this overkill for all climates? No, it’s essential for cold climates or year-round growing.

• Description: Three or more layers of polycarbonate separated by air channels, creating a highly insulating panel.
• Pros: Highest insulation (R-value), excellent light diffusion, very durable and strong.
• Cons: The most expensive polycarbonate option, reduced light transmission compared to single-wall and twin-wall (though still sufficient for most plants).
• Best Use Cases: Cold climates, year-round growing in areas with significant temperature fluctuations, situations where heating efficiency is a top priority. Ideal for maintaining stable temperatures for sensitive plants.
• Estimated Cost: The highest price point among polycarbonate options.
• Lifespan: 15+ years, often with extended warranties due to their durability.
• Thickness: Commonly available in 10mm, 16mm, and even 25mm or thicker options.

Glass – The Traditional Glazing Choice

Glass  has been the standard material for structures for centuries, valued for its exceptional clarity and classic aesthetic. It remains a popular choice for gardeners who prioritize maximum light penetration and a traditional look.

Advantages of Glass Greenhouses

• Optimal Light Transmission: Glazing allows the highest percentage of sunlight to pass through, providing the most intense light for plants. Is this always better? Not necessarily – it depends on the plant type and climate.
• Longevity: High-quality glazing, especially tempered or laminated options, can last for many decades with proper care and maintenance.
• Aesthetic Appeal: Many gardeners prefer the timeless, elegant appearance of a glazing structure. It can be a beautiful addition to any garden.

Strength and Safety Considerations

What type of glazing is best for a structure? The answer depends on your budget, safety concerns, and desired level of durability.

Horticultural Glass

Horticultural is the standard, most affordable option, but it’s also the most fragile.

• Description: Standard annealed glazing, similar to what’s used in older residential windows.
• Pros: Least expensive glazing option, excellent light transmission.
• Cons: Lowest impact resistance – shatters into sharp, dangerous shards if broken. Is it safe? It’s the least safe option, especially in areas prone to hail or strong winds.
• Best Use Cases: Sheltered locations with minimal risk of impact, budget-conscious gardeners who are willing to accept the higher risk of breakage.
• Estimated Cost: The lowest cost among glazing options.
• Lifespan: Can last for decades if not broken, but it’s highly susceptible to damage.

Toughened (Tempered) Glass

Toughened, also known as tempered, glazing is significantly stronger than horticultural glazing due to a specialized heat-treating process. How much stronger is it? Up to five times stronger.

• Description: Glazing that has undergone a controlled heating and cooling process to increase its strength and change its breakage pattern. If broken, it shatters into small, relatively harmless granular pieces instead of sharp shards.
• Pros: Much stronger than horticultural glazing, significantly safer if broken, excellent light transmission.
• Cons: More expensive than horticultural glazing.
• Best Use Cases: Areas with a moderate risk of impact (e.g., occasional hail), gardeners who prioritize safety, families with children or pets.
• Estimated Cost: Mid-range price point.
• Lifespan: Very long-lasting (decades) with proper care.

Laminated Glass

Laminated glazing provides the highest level of strength and safety. It’s constructed from multiple layers of glazing bonded together with a plastic interlayer.

• Description: Two or more layers of glazing (often tempered) bonded together with a layer of plastic, typically polyvinyl butyral (PVB). Why is this so strong? The interlayer holds the glazing together even if it cracks, preventing shattering.
• Pros: Highest impact resistance – extremely difficult to break, provides UV protection (blocks most harmful UV rays), offers some sound insulation (a minor benefit for structures).
• Cons: The most expensive glazing option.
• Best Use Cases: Areas with a high risk of impact (frequent hail, high winds, potential vandalism), situations where maximum safety and security are paramount.
• Estimated Cost: The highest price point among glazing options.
• Lifespan: Very long-lasting (decades) with proper care.

Low-E Glass

Low-E glass is designed to improve energy efficiency.

• Description: Contains multiple layers and has a metal oxide coat.
• Pros: Helps with heat and energy retention.
• Cons: Most expensive glazing option.
• Best Use Cases: High-risk areas requiring energy efficiency.
• Estimated Cost: Highest.
• Lifespan: Very long.

Head-to-Head Comparison

This table provides a direct comparison, but remember that the specific type of polycarbonate and glazing is crucial:

Feature	Polycarbonate (Twin-Wall Example)	Glass (Toughened Example)	Key Considerations
Weight	Lightweight	Heavy	Ease of installation, structural support requirements
Insulation (R-value)	Excellent (higher R-value)	Moderate (lower R-value)	Heating/cooling costs, temperature stability
Impact Resistance	High	Moderate to High	Risk of hail, wind, accidental damage
Cost (Initial)	Generally lower	Generally higher	Budget constraints
Maintenance	Low	Moderate	Cleaning frequency, potential for algae growth on glazing
Light Transmission	Good (but diffused)	Excellent (direct)	Plant type (sun-loving vs. shade-loving), climate (sunny vs. cloudy)
Light Diffusion	High (scatters light)	Low (direct light)	Prevention of hot spots and leaf burn
UV Protection	Usually included	Can be added (laminated glazing)	Protection of plants from harmful UV rays
Condensation	More prone (requires good ventilation)	Less prone	Potential for fungal diseases, humidity control
Lifespan	10-15+ years	20+ years	Long-term investment
Best For (General)	Moderate climates, good insulation, safety	Maximum light, classic look, longevity	Prioritize based on your specific needs
Framing Compatibility	Aluminum, Wood, PVC	Aluminum, Wood	Consider the weight and expansion/contraction of the glazing material.

Factors to Consider

Choosing the right material goes beyond just comparing features. Consider these crucial factors:

1. Your Local Climate

• Hot, Sunny Climates:Will my structure overheat? Multi-wall polycarbonates (for diffusion and insulation) or glazing with UV protection and good ventilation are essential to prevent excessive heat buildup.
• Cold Climates:How can I keep my structure warm? Multi-wall polycarbonates offer the best insulation (highest R-value) to minimize heat loss and reduce heating costs.
• High Wind/Hail Areas:Will my structure be damaged? Choose impact-resistant materials: twin-wall or multi-wall polycarbonates, or toughened/laminated glazing.
• Snow Loads: Check that the glazing meets the requirements.

2. Balancing Cost and Longevity

• What’s my upfront budget? Polycarbonate sheets (especially single and twin-wall) are generally less expensive than glazing.
• What’s my long-term budget? Higher-quality glazing (toughened, laminated) can last longer, potentially offsetting the higher initial cost.

3. Aesthetic Preferences

• Do I prefer a modern or traditional look? Polycarbonates tend to have a more modern appearance, while glazing offers a classic, timeless aesthetic.

4. Maintenance Requirements

• How much time am I willing to spend on maintenance? Glazing may require more frequent cleaning to maintain optimal light transmission. Polycarbonates are generally easier to clean.
• How do I deal with condensation? Proper ventilation is essential for all structures, but especially those glazed with polycarbonate.

5. Light Diffusion vs. Direct Light

• What types of plants will I be growing?
  • Sun-loving plants (tomatoes, peppers, many flowers): Benefit from the direct, intense light provided by glazing.
  • Shade-loving plants (leafy greens, ferns, orchids): Thrive with the diffused light provided by polycarbonates, which prevents leaf burn and hot spots.
  • Mixed planting: Consider a combination of glazing and polycarbonate (e.g., glazing roof for maximum light, polycarbonate sides for diffusion).

6. Installation: DIY or Professional?

• Am I comfortable with DIY installation? Polycarbonates, being lighter and less fragile, are generally easier to handle and install than heavier, more brittle glazing panels.
• Do I need professional help? Large or complex glazing structures, or those using toughened/laminated glazing, may require professional installation for safety and to ensure proper sealing.

Pros and Cons

Material	Pros	Cons
Polycarbonate (General)	Lightweight, high impact resistance, excellent insulation (especially multi-wall), UV protection, generally lower cost, easier installation.	Can scratch more easily, may yellow over time (if not UV-protected), less aesthetic appeal to some, more prone to condensation.
Single-Wall Polycarbonate	Most affordable, lightweight.	Lowest insulation, least durable.
Twin-Wall Polycarbonate	Good balance of insulation, light diffusion, and cost.	Less light transmission than single-wall or glazing.
Multi-Wall Polycarbonate	Highest insulation, most durable polycarbonate option.	Most expensive polycarbonate, reduced light transmission.
Glass (General)	Superior light transmission, long-lasting, classic aesthetic, scratch-resistant.	Heavy, more difficult to install, higher initial cost, more prone to breakage (especially horticultural glazing), requires more frequent cleaning.
Horticultural Glass	Least expensive glazing.	Most fragile, least safe.
Toughened (Tempered) Glass	Much stronger and safer than horticultural glazing.	More expensive than horticultural glazing.
Laminated Glass	Highest strength, safety, and UV protection.	Most expensive glazing option.
Low-E Glass	Helps with heat and energy.	Most expensive glazing option.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ) – Addr

• Q: Which material is absolutely better for growing vegetables?
  • A: There’s no single “best” material. It depends on the specific vegetables, your climate, and your priorities. Glazing provides maximum light intensity, which is excellent for many fruiting vegetables (tomatoes, peppers). Polycarbonates, with their light diffusion, are often preferred for leafy greens and in very sunny climates to prevent overheating.
• Q: Which material is most durable in a hailstorm?
  • A: Multi-wall polycarbonates or laminated glazing offer the highest impact resistance and are least likely to be damaged by hail.
• Q: I’m on a tight budget. What’s the most affordable option?
  • A: Single-wall polycarbonate is the least expensive glazing material, followed by horticultural glazing. However, consider the long-term costs of potential replacement due to breakage or lower energy efficiency.
• Q: How can I minimize condensation in my structure?
  • A: Proper ventilation is key, regardless of the glazing material. Ensure adequate airflow through vents, windows, and doors. Consider using anti-condensation coatings on polycarbonates.
• Q: Is there a warranty?
• A: Yes, most materials come with a warranty.
• Q: Can I mix and match glazing materials?
  • A: Yes, this is a viable option! For example, you could use glazing for the roof (for maximum light) and polycarbonates for the sides (for insulation and diffusion). This requires careful planning and a compatible framing system.

Making the Right Choice: A Personalized Decision

The “best” choice between polycarbonates and glazing for your structure isn’t a one-size-fits-all answer. It’s a personalized decision based on a careful evaluation of your specific needs, your local climate, your budget, the types of plants you intend to grow, and your aesthetic preferences. By thoroughly considering all the factors discussed in this guide, you can confidently select the glazing material that will create the optimal environment for your plants to thrive.